Dr. Casey Means’s President Trump’s team, a specialist in well -educated welfare and book author, since his next general surgeon caused a vigorous debate on Thursday about whether someone who is not a doctor in exercise serves as the main doctor of the nation.
Laura Lomer, the extreme right activist who has so much influence with Mr. Trump that more than a half national security box were fired by her advice, emerged as a vocal critic. It also did Nicole Shanahan, the former partner of the Formula of Health Robert F. Kennedy Jr., who described the choice of “very strange”.
Dr. Signia, a nearby ally or that of Mr. Kennedy, trained as a surgeon in otolaryngology (ear medicine, nose and throat, but left his surgical residence after four years to practice “functional medicine”, which focuses on the causes of the disease. She has said she was disappointed with the medical establishment and had concluded that she was failing the patients.
Mrs. Loomer ridiculed Dr. means on social networks on Thursday, calling her a “total crack boat” that “uses shrooms as” plant medicine “and talks to trees!” And “Doess does not have an active medical license.” As evidence, Mrs. Loomer published Excreperts or the weekly Bulletin of Dr. Media, in which Dr. means reflecting on recipes, product recommendations and other topics, including “changes and habits of mentality.”
Mr. Kennedy retreated with a length position in X, describing criticism as “absurd”, while Trump told journalists that he did not know Dr. Means, but chose her because “Bobby thought she was fantastic.”
Dr. Means’s brother, Calley Means, a White House advisor on health issues and former lobbyist of the food industry, defended his sister in an interview.
“Casey has inspired millions of Americans and is a threat to the status quo because he left the medical system, not despite it,” said Mr. Means.
Hey added that the family had shocked when he left his residence, “but he had a clear moral idea that his patients were not improving.”
According to the Federal Law, the General Surgeon supervises the United States Health Service Commissioner, the uniformed service that works in the first line of public health.
There are only two requirements for the work: the nominee must be a member of the body (the president usually simply appoints a candidate before he or she takes the job) and must have “specialized training or significant experience in public health programs.”
Dr. David A. Kessler, former head of the Food and Medicines Administration who also served as Dean of Yale Medicine Schools and the University of California, San Francisco, said in an interview that, although it can be legitimate reasons to criticize Dr. Media, not having a current medical license was not among them.
The main question, said Dr. Kessler, is whether a general surgeon is “well trained” in medicine. If Dr. means finishing four years of residence, he said: “She is very well trained.”
The main medical groups were largely silent about the appointment. Neinder the American Medical Association or the American Public Health Association issued statements. But Arthur L. Caplan, an outstanding medical ethical from the University of New York, described the “disabled” appointment.
“Designating Casey means, a non -practitioner who has been selling” health interventions “not tested for years, means a general surgeon who will put a marginal practitioner of functional medicine not proven in charge of educating American people about their challenges of health and disease,” Dr. Caplan wrote in an email.
By pointing out that Mr. Kennedy has asked for tests or vaccines controlled with placebo, Dr. Caplan said that the Secretary of Health must apply the same scientific rigor to the type of functional and alternative remedies Dr. Ir. It means favors. “Without data, it is similar to the execution of the radar or radio of the Newark airport,” hey.
The average brothers are media expert well -being entrepreneurs. Calley Media is the founder of Tremed, a startup that allows tax free spending on healthy supplements, exercise and food. Casey Means is the founder of Levels, a company that offers portable glucose monitors to track their health.
His hug of holistic therapies has drawn some eye rolls in the press. Rolling Stone called her “influencer woo-woo wellness.”
Dr. Means went out to fame last year after she and her brother appeared in the Tucker Carlson program to promote her diet and her self -help book, “Good Energy”, which argues that metabolic dysfunction is at the root of an epidemic of chronic diseases.
Mr. Kennedy said in X that Dr. Means’s ability to “inspire Americans to rethink our medical care system” was “an existential threat to Status Quo’s interests, which benefit from the disease.” In an interview with Fox News, she said she had “galvanized” her movement “Make America Healthy Again.”
Like Mr. Kennedy, Dr. Media has repeatedly said that the United States is in a crisis of chronic diseases. She has pointed out the growing infertility, obesity, diabetes, depression and other conditions such as proof. Also as Mr. Kennedy, she has suggested that environmental toxins and the food system are to blame.
The appointment of Dr. Means de Trump was a surprise. He announced it on Wednesday after withdrawing the nomination of his previous choice, Dr. Ir. Janette Nesheiwat, who had to appear before the Senate Health Committee on Thursday.
Dr. Nesheiwat, an urgent care doctor and former Fox News commentator, is Michael Waltz’s sister -in -law, who served as National Security Advisor of Mr. Trump until last week. He had faced criticism that he was less than present about his credentials; Mrs. Loomer complained that Dr. Nesheiwat was not “ideological aligned” with the president.
The general surgeon has no real authority to establish a policy; The power of work is on the platform and in the reports of the general surgeon. The historic 1964 report on tobacco led to warning labels in cigarette packages. Dr. C. Everett Koop, one of the best -known surgeons in the nation, used the office to advocate patients with AIDS at a time when his Republicans ignored the disease.
Dr. Vivek Murthy, who served as a general surgeon in the administrations of Obama and Biden, spoke about loneliness and mental health.
Dr. David Perlmutter, an ally or Dr. Media whose work focuses on the intersection of nutritional and neurological disorders, said the most important quality for any general surgeon is the ability to communicate science to the public.
Dr. means, he said, “Excel in that.”